Alata Magazine

Alata Magazine

Barn Burning

Affirmative action is coming to an end

Pedro L. Gonzalez's avatar
Pedro L. Gonzalez
Jan 27, 2025
∙ Paid

So hard and fast has the doctrine of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) flown off the rails that even The New York Times felt compelled to comment on the smoldering wreckage.

In October, it documented the University of Michigan's decade-long quest to impose DEI by any means necessary despite explicit bans on affirmative action. That seems especially relevant now, given that Donald Trump has returned to the White House and launched a frontal assault on this ideological hydra. Its tremendous resilience has been matched only by an enormous price tag.

The marginal utility looks limited: the sole return of an investment of $250 million into achieving the aims of the DEI since 2016 is a bureaucratic arms race. The people hailing on the successes of these affirmative action policies inevitably depend - either for status or employment - on its survival. The Ann Arbor campus grew to have more than twice the number of non-faculty employees than full-time faculty members. Black undergraduate enrollment, meanwhile, hardly improved. They have hovered from four to five percent.

But rather than enlightening its students, an intellectually and socially stifling atmosphere of fear and paranoia reigns over pupils, staff, and faculty alike. In one case, a black student named Dylan Gilbert filed a complaint against an English professor called Scott Lyons after he read aloud an excerpt from the William Faulkner short story "Barn Burning" that contained the n-word. The fact that it was a passage from an award-winning work of fiction didn’t shield him from the outrage that flew his way. The irony is that the mob that came for Lyons has much in common with the character of Abner Snopes from the story he cited, the white tenant farmer who uses the slur. More on that later.

It is not insignificant that this ordeal provoked a rebuke from an acclaimed author like Joyce Carol Oates. In a tweet, she wrote:

DEI fanaticism in Ann Arbor: intended to promote diversity, equality, inclusion on campus but in practice results in a fraught atmosphere in which everyone is scrutinizing everyone else, especially but not exclusively white professors, for "microaggressions." In the words of a professor attacked for teaching a story by Faulkner -"Like giving six-year-olds Tasers."


The history of DEI at American universities is entwined with the state's role as a spearhead of affirmative action. Indeed, it was Hobart Taylor Jr., a black lawyer and University of Michigan alumni, who coined the term "affirmative action" in 1961 and inserted it into an executive order signed by President John F. Kennedy. After the Bakke v. University of California decision in 1978 ruled racial quotas in college were impermissible, Michigan devised a blueprint for the way forward.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Alessandra Bocchi.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
Pedro L. Gonzalez's avatar
A guest post by
Pedro L. Gonzalez
Writer and editor. You can find my work in Commonweal, Washington Monthly, The Nation, The Spectator, and elsewhere. Accepting commissions.
Subscribe to Pedro
© 2026 Alessandra Bocchi · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.