What is wrong with you?
Joe Goldberg, stalker, assassin, and protagonist of the You series on Netflix, poses this fundamental question to the female sex. After five years of romance and homicide, Joe lies in his cell, reading letters of adoring women who continue to love him, despite all his murder convictions. Or perhaps, because of them.
So we should ask ourselves, what is wrong with us women? Joe, a New York librarian, finds a new female character in every series whom he adores, akin to Dante’s Beatrice, but who, in most cases, ends up killed by him. Joe is the prototype of the toxic lover: controlling, manipulative, and, ultimately, a serial murderer. Yet, notwithstanding his record, Joe was loved, idealized, and romanticized by millions of female spectators. A post from The Single’s Woman claimed, “He be killing people & still be able to text back.” The Single’s Woman further asked her readers: “Raise your hand if you want a love like the one of Joe Goldberg.” Almost five thousand women responded with a “yes”. In its first month, You attracted 40 million viewers, and was renewed for four more successful seasons. It was, however, a series impacted by controversy over the romanticization of its homicidal protagonist. Joe was too lovable to be a villain; too much of a prince to be cruel. Even the actor playing the protagonist, Penn Badgley, felt uncomfortable with the popularity surrounding his character.
So, what did women love about Joe?





